Key Takeaways
- San Joaquin County staff told supervisors they need about 10 more months to study requirements for large data centers.
- Extending the county's moratorium takes a four-fifths vote, and Supervisors Steve Ding and Paul Canepa missed last week's meeting.
- The supervisors moved the decision to their Nov. 17 meeting, where they also expected to hear more public testimony.
- The current 45-day moratorium, adopted 5-0 on Oct. 6, applies only to unincorporated parts of the county.
- No company has an application pending to build a data center in unincorporated San Joaquin County.
San Joaquin County's pause on big data centers is likely to get longer.
County staff told the San Joaquin County Board of Supervisors last week that they need to spend about 10 more months evaluating requirements for the facilities, Stocktonia reported. The supervisors now don't expect a full report until next June. That matters because the county has no rules of its own for data centers, and the moratorium is the only thing holding new projects back while officials write some.
The board couldn't act on it yet.
An extension needs a four-fifths majority, and Supervisors Steve Ding and Paul Canepa were absent. So the supervisors put the formal decision off until their Nov. 17 meeting, when they were also expected to hear more public testimony.
"At the end of the day, we need to hear from the public," Supervisor Robert Rickman said.
What the pause covers
The supervisors voted 5-0 on Oct. 6 to adopt an urgency ordinance setting a 45-day moratorium on new land-use approvals for data centers in unincorporated San Joaquin County. Stocktonia reported that it blocks the approvals a large project would need, such as general plan or zoning amendments, use permits, variances, parcel and final maps, and building or grading permits.
Smaller setups are exempt. The ordinance doesn't apply to data infrastructure used by hospitals, schools or individual businesses. It also leaves out telecommunications facilities, government emergency communications and facilities owned by public utilities.
Cities such as Tracy and Manteca aren't covered and have their own land-use authority. FOX40 reported that the pause still reaches a large stretch of land along the county's edges and about 46 communities, according to state records.
Next door in Stockton and Stanislaus County
The county's move is running roughly parallel to Stockton's. The Stockton City Council removed data centers from its three-year economic development plan and is holding public "listening sessions" around the city.
Cities in Stanislaus County got there first. Patterson and Riverbank both paused data center development, and the Patterson City Council voted Aug. 18 to stretch its 45-day moratorium to a full year, ending July 15, 2027.
What staff still wants to know
The usual questions are on the list: how much electricity a data center would draw, how much water it would use and how loud it would be. But staff say the deeper analysts dig, the more questions come up.
One is fire. County staff say the fuller report will look at whether a fire at a large battery energy storage system, or BESS, could overwhelm firefighters in small rural fire districts. Some of those batteries could be used to power the facilities. Local News Matters noted that the concern recalls the large fire at the Moss Landing Power Plant in Monterey County nearly two years ago.
Board Chair Sonny Dhaliwal made a similar point when the moratorium passed in October. "San Joaquin County does not currently have specific standards to address the unique impacts of data centers, from noise and energy demands to emergency response and infrastructure capacity," Dhaliwal said in a county news release.
Supervisor Mario Gardea put it more simply.
"Before we are put in a position to make a decision we need to be educated," he said.
Source
Read the original story from localnewsmatters.org.
